Minhaj wrote:
|
"Qur'an-alone" Muslims tend to regard the sacred months as consecutive (9:2-5).
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
However Rajab and the one before Dhul Hijjah have names connoting obvious choices.
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
If one were to look at the names of the months, the four traditional sacred months would be obvious choices. I have been looking for any historical evidence that they were consecutive (let alone starting from Dhul Hijjah, as many claim).
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
It is possible to interpret 9:2 as saying: "travel in the land four months (of the year)", just like in 9:36.
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
Which sacred months do you propose?
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
I just wanted to brush up because Sunnis have no answer. Here is 2:143 argument:
http://forums.islamicawakening.com/f15/refuting-quraniyun-44513/index17.html
Thankyou for your insight.
|
Quote:
|
The fours already known since the time of Ibrahim, in fact it was established since the time Allah decided to make the year 12 months as stated in 9:36; and certainly the info has been passed to Ibrahim who established the House and prepared it for Hajj.
|
Quote:
|
The four months already known since the time of Ibrahim, in fact it was established since the time Allah decided to make the year 12 months as stated in 9:36; and certainly the info has been passed to Ibrahim who established the House and prepared it for Hajj.
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
Well I went to the trouble of responding to ibn 'Abbad's latest post but when I logged in it said i was banned forever.
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
That tafsir you gave was exactly what I was thinking of in the other thread. It is more logical to me. Thanks for the other arguments I will include it and the website.
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
About the sacred months, I assume you include Rajab (since that is the only one I was confused about). The only other matter I was thinking of was the "months of Hajj". These did not necessarily have to be "sacred months", but they were already known months of Hajj. Do you agree with Shawwal, Dhul Qa'adah and the first ten days of Dhul Hijjah?
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
Ignoring those teachings and focussing on Qur'an-alone, the most logical thing I can think of is Dhul-Qa'ada until Muharram (plural = 3 or more). That would give three months in which Hajj can be performed. Without certainty i would advise people to do it in Dhul Qa'adah and Dhul Hijjah, but not 100% about Muharram. I don't see why not personally.
|
Minhaj wrote:
|
Thanks for the response again;
Take care
Salaam.
|
Quote:
|
I actually believe that Hajj can be performed in any of these 4 months, I know it is hard to believe but somehow I believe so according to Quran
|
Quote:
|
No worries mate, and dont be upset about those cowards banning you, you can post threads exposing them in here and I will make sure to pass a link to them, but please be tough not too polite with those arseholes
|
Thanks bro I posted it because I went to trouble of writing it. I don't speak or read Arabic I just look and see what works.
I sometimes go hard on them but if I have no time for artistic insults then I just use the logic.
Thanks again brother;
Salam;
MM
All times are GMT + 10 Hours
Powered by phpBB 2.0 .0.17 © 2001
phpBB
Group